Posted in

do air-cooled scroll chillers need a cooling tower

If you’re in the HVAC or industrial cooling space, you’ve probably heard a lot of back-and-forth about air-cooled scroll chillers—and one question that comes up again and again is whether they even need a cooling tower. As someone who’s spent 12 years selling, installing, and troubleshooting these chillers (I’ve got the scratches on my truck and the stack of customer service call logs to prove it), I get why people mix this up. A lot of folks confuse air-cooled chillers with water-cooled models, and cooling towers are basically a given for the latter. But let’s break this down straight, no jargon, no sales fluff, just what I see every day on job sites. air-cooled scroll chiller

First, let’s get the basics right. What’s an air-cooled scroll chiller, anyway? It’s a cooling unit that uses a scroll compressor (the workhorse of most small to mid-range cooling needs—think restaurants, office buildings up to 50,000 sq ft, small manufacturing facilities) and relies on ambient air to dissipate heat. A cooling tower, for those who need a quick refresher, is a big, open (or sometimes closed) structure that uses water evaporating to pull heat out of a water loop, which then cools a chiller. So right off the bat, the core design of an air-cooled scroll chiller is built to operate without a cooling tower. Let me explain why.

Air-cooled scroll chillers have a condenser coil mounted right on the unit, usually on the side or top, with fans that blow ambient air over it. That air absorbs the heat from the refrigerant that’s gone through the compression cycle, then blows that hot air out into the atmosphere. No water loop, no evaporation, no bulky tower required. That’s a huge upside for small to medium projects. I had a customer last year— a local bakery—who was replacing their old water-cooled system. They thought they needed a cooling tower, but their rooftop didn’t have space for it, and the cost to run plumbing for water lines was going to add $15,000 to their project. We installed an air-cooled scroll chiller instead, and they’ve had zero issues for 18 months. That’s the kind of win that makes customers happy.

But wait—there are edge cases, right? I don’t want to act like these chillers work for every scenario, because that’s not true. Let’s talk about when you might want to consider a cooling tower with an air-cooled scroll chiller, even if the design doesn’t technically require it. First, extreme heat. If you’re in a place where ambient temps regularly push 105°F (40°C) or higher—like parts of the Southwest US, the Middle East, or parts of Southeast Asia—ambient air can’t pull heat out of the refrigerant as well. That means the chiller has to work harder, uses more electricity, and its cooling capacity drops. In those cases, some customers will pair an air-cooled scroll chiller with a small, closed-loop cooling tower (sometimes called a fluid cooler, which is a cousin to a cooling tower) to dissipate heat more efficiently than air alone. This isn’t standard, though. Most of the time, if you’re dealing with consistent 100°F temps, we’ll actually recommend a water-cooled scroll chiller or a screw chiller instead—because pairing a cooling tower with an air-cooled unit negates a lot of the cost savings.

Another edge case: very large cooling loads. Air-cooled scroll chillers are rated up to around 150 tons, right? For most small to mid-sized buildings, that’s more than enough. But if you need 200 tons or more, you might be looking at a modular system with multiple air-cooled scroll chillers, or a larger centrifigal chiller. Even then, adding a cooling tower isn’t standard for the air-cooled models here. The only time I’ve seen it make sense is when a customer’s existing infrastructure has a cooling tower and they want to retro-fit their system to be air-cooled, but that’s rare.

Now, let’s get to the myths I hear all the time. The first one: “Air-cooled scroll chillers are less efficient than water-cooled ones.” That’s only true in extreme heat. In moderate climates—70 to 95°F ambient, which is most of the US and Western Europe—air-cooled scroll chillers are actually very efficient. Modern scroll compressors have variable speed drives, and the condenser coils have enhanced fins that make heat transfer way better than it was 10 years ago. I tested a 20-ton air-cooled scroll chiller last year in Phoenix on a 102°F day: it ran at 3.2 COP (coefficient of performance), which is way better than most water-cooled chillers paired with small cooling towers. The key is matching the unit to the climate, not just the type.

Another myth: “You need a cooling tower to prevent the chiller from overheating.” Nope. Air-cooled scroll chillers are designed with high limit switches that shut them off if the condenser air gets too hot, or if the refrigerant pressure gets too high. I’ve had units run in 108°F temps in Arizona, and as long as they’re properly sized and maintained, they don’t overheat. The only time we see overheating is when a unit is installed in a tight, enclosed space—like a utility closet with no ventilation—so the hot air from the condenser can’t escape. That’s a installation issue, not a design flaw, and it has nothing to do with cooling towers.

Let’s also talk about the practical downsides of adding a cooling tower to an air-cooled scroll chiller, just to be fair. Cooling towers require regular maintenance: you have to treat the water to prevent Legionella, algae, and scale, clean the fill media, check fans and pumps every few months. That’s extra cost and hassle for customers. Air-cooled scroll chillers only need a quick filter change every 3 to 6 months, and a coil cleaning once a year. My bakery customer told me that in the 18 months we installed their chiller, they didn’t have to schedule a single maintenance call beyond a free check-up we did, whereas their old water-cooled system needed a maintenance technician every quarter. That’s a big difference for small businesses that don’t have a dedicated facilities team.

Cost is another big one. A 20-ton air-cooled scroll chiller costs roughly $12,000 to $18,000. Add a small 10-ton cooling tower and all the plumbing, pumps, and controls, and that’s an extra $8,000 to $12,000. For a customer on a budget, that’s a dealbreaker. And don’t forget operating costs: cooling towers use water, which is a monthly expense, and pumps to circulate water, which use electricity. In moderate climates, the air-cooled chiller’s electricity savings will make up for any added cost of a cooling tower in 5 to 10 years, if at all.

Wait, but let’s make sure we’re not ignoring when a cooling tower does make sense. I had a customer in Las Vegas last year who owned a 40,000 sq ft office building. Their ambient temps hit 110°F in the summer, and their old air-cooled chiller couldn’t keep up—their office was at 78°F in the morning, and by 2pm it was 82°F. They didn’t want to tear out the existing chiller because it was only 3 years old, so we paired it with a closed-loop cooling tower that circulated a glycol-water mix through the condenser instead of air. That brought the chiller’s capacity up by 15% and cut their electricity use by 10%. But that’s a specific case: consistent extreme heat, existing infrastructure, and a chiller that’s too good to replace. That’s not the standard scenario.

So to circle back to the original question: Do air-cooled scroll chillers need a cooling tower? The short answer is no. The design of these units is inherently standalone, built to use ambient air for heat dissipation, with no requirement for water-based heat rejection. The only time you’d add a cooling tower is for a niche use case in extreme heat, or as a retro-fit for an existing system—both of which are far from the norm for most applications these units are designed for.

Now, as a supplier, I’m not here to sell you something you don’t need. If you’re building a small retail space, a restaurant, a light manufacturing facility, or a small office building, an air-cooled scroll chiller is almost always the right choice, no cooling tower required. We’ve installed over 2,000 of these units in the last 12 years, and only 12 of them had cooling towers added—all for that extreme heat scenario I mentioned earlier. If you’re not sure what’s right for your project, the best thing to do is talk to someone who knows the space: a local contractor who’s worked with air-cooled scroll chillers, or a supplier who’s got real-world experience, not just spec sheets.

If you’re evaluating options for your next cooling project, and you want to skip the hassle, cost, and maintenance of a cooling tower, let’s connect. We can talk through your load requirements, your climate, your budget, and figure out if an air-cooled scroll chiller is the right fit for you. No pressure, no pushy sales pitches, just straight answers.

Water-cooled Chiller References:

  1. Air-Conditioning, Heating, and Refrigeration Institute (AHRI). (2023). Performance Standards for Air-Cooled Scroll Liquid Chillers.
  2. ASHRAE. (2022). HVAC Applications Handbook: Cooling Systems and Equipment.
  3. U.S. Department of Energy. (2021). Advanced Chiller Technology Roadmap for Commercial and Industrial Applications.
  4. Carrier Corporation. (2020). Air-Cooled Scroll Chiller Design and Application Guidelines.
  5. International Energy Agency (IEA). (2022). Heating and Cooling in Buildings: Market Trends and Emissions Outlook.

Hangzhou Dayu HVAC Engineering Co., Ltd.
As one of the most professional air-cooled scroll chiller manufacturers and suppliers in China, we have world-leading production equipment and strong manufacturing capabilities. If you’re going to buy customized air-cooled scroll chiller made in China, welcome to get quotation from our factory. For price consultation, contact us.
Address: Room 1004, Building 1, Xicheng Business Tower, Xihu District, Hangzhou City, Zhejiang Province, China
E-mail: info@hi-hvac.com
WebSite: https://www.hi-hvac.com/